One Piece is an emotional rollercoaster filled with thrilling battles, laughter, and heartbreaking moments. One of the most heart-wrenching scenes in the series is the death of Portgas D. Ace during the Marineford War. Ace’s death was a significant turning point in the story, and it left fans wondering: Why did Garp let Ace die? In this blog post, we’ll explore Garp’s motivations, beliefs, and emotions that led to this tragic outcome.
Section 1: Garp’s Dual Loyalties
As a Vice Admiral in the Marines and a member of the D. family, Garp is a man torn between two worlds. On one hand, he has dedicated his life to serving justice and maintaining order as a Marine. On the other, he carries the weight of the D. family name, a lineage known for its rebellious nature and history of challenging the status quo.
Related: Shanks vs. Kaido: Who is Stronger?
1.1 Duty to the Marines
Garp’s primary loyalty is to the Marines and the cause of justice. As a Marine, he has faced countless pirates and criminals, always striving to protect the innocent and uphold the values of the World Government. His unwavering dedication to his duty has made him a legendary figure within the Marine ranks and earned him the title of “Hero of the Marines.”
1.2 Family Ties
Despite his commitment to the Marines, Garp also harbors a deep love for his family. He took in both Ace and Luffy, raising them alongside his own son, Dragon. This love is evident in the way he guides and trains them, trying to steer them away from the path of piracy. Garp’s love for his family is genuine, but it often comes into conflict with his duty as a Marine.
Section 2: Ace’s Fate
Portgas D. Ace, the son of the Pirate King Gol D. Roger, was destined for a life of notoriety and infamy. Despite Garp’s efforts to guide him on the right path, Ace eventually embraced his pirate heritage and joined the Whitebeard Pirates. This choice put Ace directly at odds with Garp’s Marine loyalties.
2.1 Ace’s Capture
Ace’s fateful encounter with the Marine Admiral Akainu led to his capture by the World Government. As a high-ranking member of the Whitebeard Pirates and the son of Gol D. Roger, Ace’s execution was meant to be a symbol of the Marines’ power and a crushing blow to the pirate world.
2.2 The Marineford War
Whitebeard’s determination to save his beloved son, Ace, led to the outbreak of the Marineford War, a massive conflict that pitted the Whitebeard Pirates and their allies against the full might of the Marines. This war put Garp in an impossible situation: to fulfill his duty as a Marine, he had to stand against his own family.
Section 3: Garp’s Dilemma
Caught between his duty and his love for Ace, Garp faced a heart-wrenching decision during the Marineford War. As the conflict raged on, it became increasingly clear that there was no easy way out.
3.1 Upholding Justice
Throughout the Marineford War, Garp remained steadfast in his loyalty to the Marines. He understood that allowing Ace to escape would be a betrayal of his duty and the principles he had sworn to uphold. By choosing to let Ace die, Garp, maintained his commitment to justice, even at the cost of his own family.
3.2 Sacrificing Family
As much as it pained him, Garp ultimately decided that he could not defy Marine’s orders and save Ace. He was forced to confront the harsh reality that his dual loyalties had put him in a no-win situation. By choosing his duty over his family, Garp sacrificed his relationship with Ace and the happiness of his own family for the sake of the greater good.
Section 4: The Emotional Toll
The tragic outcome of the Marineford War left a lasting impact on Garp, both personally and professionally. Watching Ace die in Luffy’s arms was a heartbreaking moment that would haunt him for the rest of his life.
4.1 Grief and Regret
Garp’s decision to let Ace die was not made lightly, and the emotional toll it took on him was immense. He was filled with grief and regret for not being able to save Ace, questioning whether he had made the right choice. This pain was only exacerbated by the fact that Luffy, his other grandson, had to witness Ace’s death firsthand.
4.2 Strained Relationships
In the aftermath of the Marineford War, Garp’s relationships with his family members, particularly Luffy and his own son Dragon, were severely strained. Garp’s decision to prioritize his duty over his family created an emotional rift that may never fully heal.
Section 5: Conclusion
Monkey D. Garp’s decision to let Ace die during the Marineford War was a painful and heart-wrenching choice. Torn between his duty as a Marine and his love for his family, Garp ultimately chose to uphold the values of justice and order that he had sworn to protect. This decision carried a heavy emotional toll, leaving Garp with grief, regret, and strained relationships with his family.
In the end, Garp’s choice reflects the complex and often contradictory nature of the One Piece world, where even the most legendary figures are faced with difficult decisions and moral dilemmas. While it’s impossible to say whether Garp made the “right” choice, his decision to let Ace die serves as a poignant reminder of the sacrifices that come with a life dedicated to duty and the pursuit of justice.